By Ferhan Bugay, Executive Director, Aero Support Group · 16 November 2026
Most aviation audits check whether a process meets a requirement. Few check whether the process can perform: whether it is designed end to end, whether someone owns it, whether the people in it know how their work affects the result, and whether the organisation around it can support improvement. The Process Audit Tool answers those questions. It is adapted from Michael Hammer’s Process and Enterprise Maturity Model, described in “The Process Audit” (Harvard Business Review, April 2007), and it is the tool we use most in our own process work. You can download it free at the end of this article.
Why process maturity matters in aviation
Regulators and IATA audits increasingly look at how a management system works, not only at what the manual says. A maintenance exposition can describe every procedure and still leave nobody responsible for how the work flows from planning to release. A ground handler can pass a document review and still see the same loading errors month after month. The cause is usually the same: the process is managed department by department, with no owner for the whole flow, no end-to-end measures and no one with the authority to change it.
Copying regulation text into a manual does not fix that. The tool asks who does the work, how it is done, who reviews it, who monitors the process and where the record is kept.
What the tool assesses
The tool looks at one process and at the organisation around it.
| Process enabler | Sub-dimensions |
|---|---|
| Design | Purpose, context, documentation |
| Performers | Knowledge, skills, behaviour |
| Owner | Identity, activities, authority |
| Infrastructure | Information systems, HR systems |
| Metrics | Definition, uses |
| Enterprise capability | Sub-dimensions |
|---|---|
| Leadership | Awareness, alignment, behaviour, style |
| Culture | Teamwork, customer focus, responsibility, attitude to change |
| Expertise | People, methodology |
| Governance | Process model, accountability, integration |
Each sub-dimension has four level statements. For a process they run from P-1 Stable (defined and followed, even if still organised around departments) to P-2 End to end, P-3 Integrated with other processes and IT, and P-4 Best in class, extended to customers and suppliers. For the organisation they run from E-1 Ready to start to E-2 Able to redesign, E-3 Process-managed and E-4 Extended enterprise. The level statements are written in our own words for aviation and other regulated organisations.
How the scoring works
Every level statement is scored from 0 to 4 on the same scale we use in our SMS and ISO 9001 tools: 0 not present, 1 present (documented), 2 suitable, 3 operating, 4 effective. A statement counts as achieved when the consensus score reaches 3. Up to five assessors score independently, the tool flags rows where they differ by two points or more, and it warns when a score of 3 or more rests on documents only.
The levels are gated. A sub-dimension reaches level 2 only if levels 1 and 2 are both achieved; a strong level 4 statement cannot make up for a missing level 1. Each element then takes the level of its weakest sub-dimension, and the process takes the level of its weakest enabler. That is how Hammer’s model works, and it is why the result often surprises management: one weak area, such as an owner without authority, holds the whole process at a lower level.
An index between 0 and 4 shows progress between levels, so a second assessment shows movement even before the next level is reached.
What you get
- Process maturity from P-1 to P-4 and enterprise maturity from E-1 to E-4.
- A level and index for each enabler, capability and sub-dimension.
- An action plan in which the sub-dimensions holding an element down are marked high priority, with the next level statement shown as the target.
- A calibration view of where the assessors disagreed.
Where we use it
We use the tool for a baseline before a process redesign, to check the result after the redesign, and as an annual check of process maturity. In aviation it works well for processes that cross departments: maintenance planning to release, occurrence reporting to corrective action, ground handling from booking to departure, and document control across a management system. It is also a practical way to test whether an exposition or operations manual describes a process that someone actually owns and manages, which is what we look for when we review MOEs and manuals before an authority or IATA audit.
How to run an assessment
- Pick one process and agree its scope, owner and start and end points. Fill in the setup sheet.
- Score the process enablers and the enterprise capabilities independently, statement by statement. Do not stop at the first level that fails.
- Log the evidence seen and the document or record references.
- Hold a consensus session on the flagged rows and the documents-only warnings.
- Build the improvement plan from the high-priority rows, then repeat the assessment after the changes. Copy the workbook for each further process; the enterprise sheet can be reused.
How ASG can help
ASG facilitates process maturity assessments and process redesign for airlines, MROs, ground handlers and airports, and builds manuals that describe processes people own and run. See our management system consulting or write to info@aerosupport360.com.
References
- Hammer, M. “The Process Audit”, Harvard Business Review, April 2007
- The tool is adapted from Hammer’s Process and Enterprise Maturity Model (PEMM). The level statements and scoring method are Aero Support Group’s own; the tool is not affiliated with or endorsed by Hammer and Company.
Free download: Process Audit Tool
An Excel workbook with process enablers and enterprise capabilities, gated maturity levels, scoring for up to five assessors, a dashboard and an action plan. Leave your details and the download link opens straight away; we also send it by email.
We use your details to send you the download link and to follow up on your request. If you tick the box above, we will also send you occasional ASG updates. We do not share them with third parties. See our Privacy Policy.
Frequently asked questions
An assessment of whether a process is able to perform: how it is designed, who owns it, what performers know, what systems support it and how it is measured. It looks at capability, not only compliance with a requirement.
The structure is adapted from Michael Hammer’s Process and Enterprise Maturity Model, described in “The Process Audit” (Harvard Business Review, April 2007). The level statements and scoring method are ASG’s own.
The levels are gated and each element takes the level of its weakest sub-dimension, as in Hammer’s model. A strong area cannot make up for a missing foundation.
Yes. It suits processes that cross departments, such as maintenance planning to release or occurrence reporting to corrective action, and it complements regulatory audits by showing whether the process is owned and managed end to end.
Yes. Leave your details in the form and the download link opens straight away. We also send it by email.
Subscribe to Global Aviation Safety Radar
Weekly aviation safety and compliance intelligence covering ICAO, IATA, EASA, and UK CAA developments — translated into practical implications for airlines, MROs, airports, ground handlers, and aviation leaders.